
We’ve made it to the third and final week of our Christmas Cookies in July series! I was hoping to get more varieties in, but 3 is a good start. For the third entry in the series, I decided to make watermelon smile cookies. After all, what is more summery than watermelon? When I…

Hi there! I’m so happy you’ve found your way to my kitchen. Welcome to I Wanna Bake, a space dedicated to simple, delicious, and joy-filled baking. Whether you’re a total beginner who has never cracked an egg or a home baker looking for your next go-to recipe, you’re in the right place.

New and Improved Strawberry Pie You might recall that my husband and I created a chocolate strawberry pie many moons ago that we ended up serving at our wedding (among others). Sadly, Josh had to make some drastic dietary changes about a year or so ago, one of which involves strictly limiting the amount of chocolate he consumes. …

Happy belated Independence Day! My procrastination worked out well enough this time, as I’ve got a dessert based on Captain America: The First Avenger, a.k.a. Marvel’s most star-spangled, patriotic superhero, to share with you today. I will confess that I’d been putting this one off because I just couldn’t get into any of the ideas I…

Pumpkin Spice Rugelach Happy Hanukkah to all who celebrate! In case you’re jonesing for some cookies that are holiday-appropriate but still a little out of the ordinary, I’ve concocted this recipe for Pumpkin Spice Rugelach. I feel like fall came and went in an instant, and I’m still not ready to let go of pumpkin…

Posted on December 2 by Katie Gaffen Cinnamon pie is something I’ve been tinkering with ever since I saw this episode of Psych for the first time (as an aside, why aren’t cinnamon festivals more of a thing?!). As it turns out, cinnamon pie sounds easier to come up with than it is. In my mind, it should have a…

Posted on 3 Hours Ago by Katie Gaffen Happy New Year! I hope everyone’s off to a great start to 2016 so far (and adjusting faster to writing 2016 in dates than I am)! I don’t know about you, but even I have just about hit my limit on sweets throughout the holiday season. Because of this sugar…